Soft-copy reading has been cleared by the FDA. Now it is up to the vendors to get their
digital mammography systems to market

(left to right) CTI Breast Cancer System 2100; R2
Technology Checkmate review monitor; Fischer SenoScan
Arguably, there has never been another time when so much emphasis has been focused on
womens healthcare. For some time, digital mammography has been poised to take off,
but it was not until November did the FDA give its clearance to soft-copy reading from
digital images.
With its approval of GE Medical Systems Senographe 2000D for soft-copy reads,
potential vendors and market observers say the FDA and GEMS have cleared the way for
digital mammography to become a viable product in the medical imaging industry.
One of the next milestones for mammography equipment makers to keep watch for is the
next round of Mammography Quality Standards Act (MQSA) regulations, which take affect in
2002.
Regulatory clearance of soft-copy reads is expected to have a significant effect on
computer-aided detection (CAD) equipment, which provides a level of diagnostic assurance
in the detection of early-stage breast cancer.
R2 Technology Inc. (Los Altos, Calif.) developed the first FDA-cleared CAD system (in
1998) that provides computerized image analysis of digital mammography images.
At RSNA 2000, R2 Technology featured the launch of its 2.2 version of ImageChecker. The
processing system converts mammographic films to digital images to permit analysis using
algorithms that detect and mark suspicious areas for further review. The processor unit is
available as a single loader that digitizes and analyzes one examination at a time. The
continuous loader model is capable of delay-free loading 80 films at a time, each marked
with an individual bar code to avoid identification errors.
R2 Technology also rolled out its new CheckMate review monitor with touch screen
interface. A flat-panel design, this monitor can be wall-mounted near a lightbox or placed
on a desktop or near any existing motorized viewer.
R2 also unveiled its LungCheck as a works-in-progress CAD for the early detection of
lung nodules using a low dose CT scan. The system is poised to begin FDA trials. R2 also
has in development CR or DR lung CAD systems for the early detection of lung nodules.
Scanis Inc. (Foster City, Calif.) introduced its latest version of the Mammex TR for
evaluation of mammography. Currently distributed in Europe and Canada, the system is
considered an investigational device in the United States.
In a pre-clinical evaluation at the Norris Comprehensive Cancer Center at the
University of Southern California, the system was used in a true screening environment.
Chapman said that the system did not increase the patient recall rate and reduced the
reading time of the least-skilled physician (a post doctoral fellow) in the department.
CadX Medical Systems (Laval, Quebec, Canada) offered the Second Look CAD breast system.
Currently installed at 16 sites in Europe, clinical trials are currently underway in the
United States. CadX anticipates submitting its application for clearance to the FDA early
in 2001.
Using technology that was developed in the fields of image processing and artificial
intelligence, Second Look uses proprietary algorithms to identify suspicious
microcalcifications and masses from a mammogram.
TransScan Medical Inc. (Ramsey, N.J.) offers impedance imaging as an adjunct to
traditional mammography with its patented T-Scan 2000 breast imaging system. The latest
version includes improvements in software.
All software is upgradeable, said Hal Kirshner, chairman, president and CEO
of TransScan. None of these systems will become obsolete. Free upgrades are
available for the next five years.
The system is used to evaluate ambiguous mammography results when a physician is
deciding whether to biopsy a suspicious lesion. Research suggests that T-Scan, when used
in an adjunct capacity, has the potential to substantially reduce negative biopsies while
increasing the net number of cancers detected.
Approved as a non-invasive adjunctive diagnostic tool in April 1999, the system has
been FDA-approved only as an adjunct to traditional mammography.
The Diamond breast care system by Instrumentarium Imaging Inc. (Milwaukee) was
showcased at RSNA. The Delta 32 is the digital camera at the heart of the system, and TACT
is a 510(k)-cleared digital software option that reconstructs a 3D image from a 2D image
taken with the digital receptor.
ECS (easy compression system) is another exclusive feature of the Diamond. As a
nonconventional method of field preparation, bi-directional compression of breast tissue
is more comfortable for the patient and includes more breast tissue in the imaged area.
Introduced as a works-in-progress, TACT 3D images renderings from C-arms is under
development. Using the same algorithms as the breast imaging system, the company will be
entering FDA trials in the future.
Hologic Inc. (Bedford, Mass.) comes to RSNA having transformed itself from a bone
densitometry company to a much broader radiology solutions company.
In mammography, Hologic has made the decision to discontinue the former Trex Medical
Corp. (Danbury, Conn.) Bennett line and keep the Lorad products.
At RSNA, Hologic was most proud of its new works-in-progress 25 cm-by-29 cm digital
detector for full-field digital mammography. The detector features selenium coating on a
thin-film transistor matrix for enhanced image quality and dose efficiency. Hologic hopes
to have the detector ready for the market by the end of 2001, if all regulatory approvals
are received.
If and when it is FDA-cleared, Hologic plans to use the selenium detector to upgrade
its Lorad M-IV mammography system to an M-IV Platinum model.
Hologic also introduced the Lorad M-650 mammography system, which the company will
position in the mid-$60,000 range, just below the Lorad M-IV. The M-650 will be available
in international markets initially; plans are to have it in the U.S. market by September.
Following a major company reorganization, Fischer Imaging Corp. (Denver) launched its
SenoScan.
The SenoScan full-field digital mammography system is designed for breast cancer
screening and diagnostic procedures. Using Fischers slot scanning technology, which
scans a thin X-ray beam across the breast concurrent with an array of CCD sensors below,
the system can provide an image resolution of 50 microns. The system is designed to reduce
radiation dose to the patient, while improving the resolution of the images for both
screening and diagnostic purposes. Used in its ultra-high resolution mode, the system can
produce images with pixels as small as 25 microns.
Fischer has completed an FDA reader study for SenoScan. The data currently is under
analysis, with submission anticipated soon. Just prior to RSNA, Fischer Imaging and CADx
announced an agreement to integrate the CADx Second Look software into Fischers
SenoScan system.
GE Medical Systems Senographe 2000D is still the only FDA-cleared full-field
digital mammography system.
There are more than 100 systems installed globally, with more than 50 in the
U.S., said Samantha Allison, general manager, womens healthcare business.
We expect to have 70 installed by the end of [2000].
GEMS also reports a developing works-in-progress in partnership with R2 Technologies to
incorporate CAD into GEMS digital mammography system. Allison added that GEMS plans
to file for FDA approval in early 2001.
Tomosynthesis 3D is another GEMS works-in-progress. Working in collaboration with
Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH of Boston), the system uses 11 exposures of breast
tissue to produce planar views to aid diagnosis.
GEMS also highlighted a partnership with Pronosco (Vedbaek, Denmark) to add bone
density screening capabilities to the GEMS traditional film-screen mammography system. The
X-posure system from Pronosco currently is available in general radiography rooms, takes
an X-ray image of the hand, digitizes it, and uses algorithms to assess bone mineral
density as an osteoporosis screen.
GEMS hopes to have FDA clearance for the combined product in early 2001.
Computerized Thermal Imaging (CTI of Layton, Utah) is seeking premarket approval (PMA)
from the FDA for its Breast Cancer System 2100, a noninvasive, radiation-free unit that
provides a physiological view of the breast without compressing the breast.
CTIs Breast Cancer System 2100 consists of three elements: a heat-sensitive
digital camera that acquires the data, computer software that analyzes the data, and the
clinical evaluation of the data.
Lynn Satterthwaite, CTI vice president of engineering, said the price for the procedure
is expected to be competitive with traditional mammography at a range of $100 to $300 per
patient.
iMammogram.com (Westlake Village, Calif.), meanwhile, offers its CloserLook
service, which provides women and their doctors with a computer-aided detection (CAD)
analysis of their mammograms.
CloserLook from iMammogram.com uses FDA-approved CAD technology for mammograms
the ImageChecker from R2Technology to detect early signs of cancer on screening
mammograms.
Eastman Kodak Co.s (Rochester, N.Y.) Health Imaging division debuted a new
premium X-Sight medical imaging system for general radiography. The new X-Sight G/RA film
is both high-resolution and high-contrast for applications which require fine details. The
new Kodak X-Omat Multiloader 7000 offers high-capacity daylight loading in a system about
half the size of the X-Omat Multiloader 700 and has a lower price point.